A carrier report, or a ranked morning list for the states you buy?

Both products start from public FMCSA filings and estimate renewal timing from the filing effective date. Insight Carrier sells that as a state-limited lead list with quote tools. DOT Intel keeps the estimate labeled and puts the carrier record in one report.

Side by side

DOT Intel vs Insight Carrier

Only capabilities we could actually verify — either present, or checked for and not found. Anything we could not confirm says so, rather than being guessed in either direction.

Renewal timing

DOT Intel

Partial or qualified: An estimated renewal window is the next anniversary of the current filing effective date, rebuilt nightly, with a high, medium, or low confidence label. It is an estimate. Confirm the date with the insured. The arithmetic is on the methodology page.

Insight Carrier

Yes: Insight Carrier says renewal dates are estimated from the filing effective date and a standard 12-month term, and that actual dates can differ. Hot leads are described as renewing in 30 to 60 days with extra shopping signals; Warm and Watch cover the rest of a 90-day window.

What you open in the morning

DOT Intel

Partial or qualified: Search carriers and open a report that joins authority, filings, fleet, and safety context. Estimated timing stays labeled as a model.

Insight Carrier

Yes: A Hot, Warm, and Watch list for the states on the plan, with CSV export and a data date printed on the page and the file. The homepage checked on 14 Nov 2026 was stamped 11-14-2026.

Quote and follow-up tools

DOT Intel

Partial or qualified: The carrier report supports the call. Pipeline and Submission Desk are optional. Verified-domain email sequences are marked coming soon.

Insight Carrier

Yes: The published plans include a CRM, an AI-assisted pre-filled trucking application, a loss-run request portal, and broker-of-record letters. Extra users are 19 dollars a month each on the 2-, 7-, and 12-state plans.

Published price

DOT Intel

Partial or qualified: Published — 100 distinct carrier records free over the account lifetime, with no monthly reset and no card, then $25 Producer, $49 Producer Plus, or $100 Agency Team per month. Every paid plan includes the same product tools; only included users and monthly carrier and lead-row volume differ.

Insight Carrier

Partial or qualified: As checked 14 Nov 2026: 149 dollars a month for 2 states, 199 dollars a month for 7 states, and 249 dollars a month for 12 states. A 13-state-and-above price was not published. The 2-state plan describes a 5-day money-back guarantee for the first subscription per agency.

Insight Carrier claims as checked 14 Nov 2026 on the pages linked below. DOT Intel pricing follows the plan copy in this site. A 13-state-and-above Insight Carrier price was not on the page, so none is quoted.

The honest read

Where each product is stronger

Insight Carrier is stronger for a producer who wants a state-limited morning call list, a Hot/Warm/Watch rank, a stamped data date, and loss-run and broker-of-record letters in the same subscription.

DOT Intel is the carrier report and the labeled estimate. The methodology page shows the anniversary arithmetic, including when the confidence label is high, medium, or low. The estimate is a question for the insured, and the report is meant to be read before the call.

Questions producers ask

Does Insight Carrier publish a confirmed renewal date?
Its own page says the dates are estimated from the filing effective date and a standard 12-month term, and that the carrier should confirm them. DOT Intel uses the same class of estimate and labels confidence on the methodology page.
Which product includes loss-run and broker-of-record letters?
Insight Carrier lists a loss-run request portal and broker-of-record letters on every published plan. Those letter tools are not part of the DOT Intel comparison facts on this page.

Read the carrier record before you buy a state list

Open a USDOT, see the filing history and the estimated window, and compare that with a state-pack lead list.